17 Alternatives to Shock Collars [Infographic]

Table of Contents

Despite still being widely used , jolt collars for dogs are consider by many owner and some trainer as an inhumane and impractical method acting of training a dog .

Studies foundthat tag respond to positive reinforcement far more successfully than negative reinforcing stimulus .

So why not try something else before repair to a tool that ’s potentially dangerous for your canine tooth ?

While some dog trainersagree — when used by rights , cushion collars for dogscanbe a dependable and effective method of hound training — it takes a flock of body of work on the favorite possessor ’s part .

You must be well - educate and prepare on the dependable function of frank shock collars , know the right methods , and only expend the highestquality brandsthat may be very expensive .

It ’s true that some dogs are more difficult to train than others .

However , even if blow dog collar for dogs may be used safely , there are a bunch of other non - harmful options that can and should be explore beforehand for train your canine .

The below infographic list a whopping 17 ways to train dogs without make them bother .

You ’ll postulate to be ordered and patient with whichever stupor collar alternatives you pick out .

Like this infographic ? unfold the word ! deal it on your site :

< p> Please include attribution to TopDogTips.com with this graphic.

17 Alternatives to Shock Collars for Dogs

1. Clicker Training

Clicker training is arguably the good tool for training your hot dog and is the act onealternativeto shock shoe collar for dogs .

blackguard flight simulator and pet owners likewise found this to be the most in force pawl breeding approach , anda 2016 studyseems to have sustain the experience of those preparation with clickers .

The field of study also demonstrated how trainers can later interchange to simple commandswithoutclickers and still achieve the same results .

The method is childlike : by using aclicker toolwith a instruction and reward your wiener with congratulations or a andiron treat when they follow through , you create a confirming connection with the clicker .

It ’s Conditioning 101 .

For example , if your dog barks at the mailman and you do n’t want them to , you could practice the clicker to call them to you — something they will do if ask that positive strengthener .

2. Obedience Training

Problem barking or problem behaviour that are remedied with shock collars for dogs are often the result of deeply - seated exit .

Dogs barque for manydifferent reasons , and it may be that your bow-wow has too small socialization , has an unseated care , or simply does n’t know how to act in a specific situation .

Ina 2014 discipline , researcher compared two training methods : blow dog collar for dogs vs obedience alongside reward - based training .

They found that electronic collars cause distress in darling and make new elusive behaviors , while obedience and reward - base training were efficient access for fixing behavioural problem in canines .

To do this , you could record some basic obedience books ( or consult with a professional trainer ) and then work with your dog on obedience with reward - based training as well as exposure to foreign stimuli while exert a positive atmosphere .

Rather than punishing a symptom , this will get to the antecedent of your dogtooth ’s job doings .

3. Reward Desirable Behavior

speak of wages - based training , as the above - mentioned subject field indicated , frankfurter respond very well to praise and positive reinforcing stimulus .

Further enquiry has confirmed this .

For good example , a 2013 studyfound that dogs do not respond well to penalty or negative reinforcement , while rewarding dog’sgoodbehavior had the best breeding results .

This is best explained as such :

I ask you to do something , and you do n’t empathise what I am asking you to do . You try it anyway but do the incorrect thing . Instead of showing you the correct affair to do and tie in it with congratulations , I punish you for doing the wrong affair and echo my original command . Once again , you endeavor to do what I ’ve asked but regain it very difficult when you do n’t understand what I want from you .

you’re able to see how this becomes problematic .

I can penalize you a million times for doing the haywire thing , but because you are a firm fellow and friend , you will go on prove . Through this process , you get wind nothing except that when I ask you to do something , and you assay to do it , you get penalize .

Shock collars for dogs essentially represent this process .

Now , consider that I hold on and work with you rather than against you .

I praise you while exhibit you the correct affair to do .

This create a plus affiliation between the “ right-hand thing ” and my command .

From this deterrent example , you could see how convinced reinforcement works in a much more effective way than negative reinforcement .

4. Use Distractions

As one of the alternative to daze collars for dogs to prevent bark effect , it ’s best to use dissimilar methods to unhinge your positron emission tomography from the thing that ’s making them bark . Doing this regularly will learn your pooch that the matter they are skin at is not worth their attention and there is something better to do alternatively . This is one of the most efficacious methods tostop dogs from barkingspecifically .

For example , if your dog barks every fourth dimension they see the mailman , keep a dog goody on hand the next metre you bear the postman to arrive . Keep your hotdog distracted with the treat and reassure him that he ’s a “ good male child ” . They may keep to be trouble by the postman , but it ’s your caper to keep them interested in the treat . Once the mailman go by , praise your hound for not barking and give them the treat .

5. Have a Clear Vocabulary

Often , when a cad “ misbehaves , ” it ’s because they lack sympathy of what they are expected to do .

This lack of understanding can leave from not having the necessary vocabulary to reference . At this full point , owners assume that their positron emission tomography is “ untrainable ” and repair to jolt collar for dogs .

However , cuspid really see more than we call up .

Ina 2016 study , researchers discovered how finicky dogs are when owner attempt to “ talk ” to them .

They observe and can severalize speech patterns , vocabulary words , and intonation of human talking to .

Thus , the issue with the above job is because of unconventional communicating .

you may remedy this by teaching your pooch a more extensive and clear vocabulary .

build your dog ’s lexicon is one of the easiest shock leash alternative you’re able to apply that is much more humane than unnecessarily administering a shock when they misbehave .

6. Recruit a Behavioral Trainer

Depending on your individual ducky , wiener breeding can become tedious and take many hours to achieve any results .

If you are get problem cultivate with your pet through their behavioral problems , consider hiring a professional dog trainer or canine behaviorist .

A professional has experience working with similar problems and can help you and your Fido work through them without repair to shock collars for dogs .

As I ’ve remark above , there are flight simulator who habituate dog jolt collars .

Fortunately , they are much better at using them safely than the bulk of pet owners .

But if this still rest a concern for you , then pick an expert who fall back to shock collar option instead .

A behavioral trainer will build up your dog ’s confidence and improve their doings by getting to the cause of the problem rather than punishing the symptom .

7. Adequate Exercise

Dogs will often misconduct or act out when they have excess energy .

This is particularly true forhyperactive dogsand breeds prone to extreme instance of hyperactivity .

For good example , when your dog sees the carrier , barks , and take to the woods to the front door , they may be bark because they , too , desire to be out of doors and expend some of their work up - up DOE .

Your frank ’s “ misbehavior ” could have nothing to do with a job barking at all but rather a desire to exercise , run , play , and be outdoors .

Experts notehow it ’s the only direction for high - energy dog breed to behave until they ’re tired .

Therefore , alternatively of fall back to stupor collars for dogs as a way to lay off your doggie from run outside in this case , try out increasing your pet ’s daily exercise and see if this aid .

8. Build Trust

The biggest matter you may do to create a better - behaved and more obedient heel is make a solid trust adhesion .

If your frump understands you are trustworthy , they will be more likely to keep up your command and trust your training methods .

If you suppose that it sounds like woo - woo hooey , take a look atthis 2016 studythat get how dog wo n’t trust raging owners and their specific conduct .

Meaning , they wo n’t react to your command or listen to what you tell them to do . And ina 2015 bailiwick , scientists found how dogs can name liars and not trust them , either .

Therefore , when you make a lack of trust by using shock collars for dogs or otherwise punishing your pets , it ’s possible that you are severalize them that they can not trust you .

You are produce a level of uncertainty , which will further perplex your future dog breeding efforts .

9. Have Empathy

Do n’t accept that because you see your dog ’s behavior as misbehavior , it is actually so .

Try using a little empathy and observing the world from your weenie ’s point of view .

canvas thereasonsfor your frump ’s bark : perhaps they are barking at the mailman because they are afraid .

Perhaps they are bark because the mailman is trespass on your property , and they are trying to protect you .

When you depend at the state of affairs with empathy , it becomes easier to see how you might remedy the post .

For example , if you think your bow-wow may be barking because he is afraid , try introducing your dog to the mailman . Have the mailman bid your weenie goody with a genial and easy articulation .

If you think your Fido is just protect their property , take them on a tercet to greet the postman in a friendly articulation .

Show them that you are permitting him to be there and glad to see him .

Not only is this a more human shock collar alternative , but it ’s also a much faster and more efficacious way of life to amend your dog ’s barking job .

10. Desensitization

Desensitizationis one of the most crucial ways that you’re able to help your Fido to work through behavioural problems .

It ’s a unconscious process that involve exposing your dog to stimulation that are upsetting them or causing them to act out , which is often the main case of a phone number of canine behavioral issues .

pic should be gradual and involve plenty of praise and treats .

This helps to make a positive connection with the stimulus , which can be reinforced over clock time .

Repeated picture with positive reinforcement finally reframes how your dog sees a specific stimulus .

Again , this gets to the core of the job rather than punishing the symptom with the use of shock collars for dog or other electronegative approaches to training .

11. Reassurance

There are some who believe that reassure your wiener when they are afraid or confused is the ill-timed affair to do .

However , more late research suggests that reassuring your dog helps to build their trust in you .

Ina 2017 study , scientists discover how dogs can “ smell ” your fear , and if you ’re not reassured , they will get scared too .

For example , if your dog is afraid that the mailman is someone come in to anguish his phratry and he barks out of fright and a desire to scare him away , dismissing your dog will instruct them that you are not to be believe .

It distinguish your frump that their fears are being displace and their concern for you is unimportant .

If , however , you recognize your bounder ’s reaction and reassure them that everything is okay , you tell your detent that ( a ) they are secure , ( b ) you recognize their effort at protecting you , and ( c ) they can believe you not to push aside their belief about the office .

Once again , this is not only a more human approaching than shock collars for dogs but a much easy and more pleasant one for both you and your pooch .

12. Crating

If your wiener has a exceptional trigger that makes him oppose negatively and you have tried and fail to make through that behaviour , try turn to crate training instead .

Because of some cherry - picked alarmist news program , some best-loved owners conceive crating is inhuman ; however , the opposite is true .

When done aright , crating is beneficial for both training and the dog ’s psychology , harmonise toStanley Coren , Ph.D.

In the most basic sense , crate hound training provides your pet with a safe resort that they can look for out when feel imperil or afraid .

Teaching your dog to find their secure place alternatively of trouble bark is a more constructive answer to the egress for you both .

The majority of professional hot dog trainers , include APDT , consort on the use ofdog crate .

13. Ambient Noise

Some dog expose job behaviors due to anxiety or restiveness .

For example , your dog may bark every time they take heed someone pass in the hallway of your flat coordination compound .

They do this because they believe that someone is in their territorial dominion or they are calling for tending .

alternatively of using shock collars for dogs to finish your pooch from skin , you may use a “ haphazardness glide slope , ” and there are dissimilar methods .

For good example , a white noise machine , playing the tuner , provide the TV on , or pickingcalming musicfor dogs to drown out that triggering haphazardness .

This will not only help your dog palpate more at ease but also decoct barking , which is plaguy to your neighbors , without punishment .

Studies havefoundthat ambient racket is one of the most in effect methods for anxious dogs .

14. Pheromones or Scents

For dogs that exhibit trouble behavior out of anxiety or excitability , pheromone or scents can help to calm them .

Pheromones and smell can be used as plugins , they can be fitted as disc on wienerwurst collar , and they can be propagate like essential oil .

All of these thing can stimulate a feeling of calm and stop your dog from acting out without using shock collars for dogs or other penalty .

In fact , scientist have screen pheromone as a way to calm down dogs to see how in force this method is .

Several studies , unsurprisingly to pet possessor who ’ve tried it , discovered that pheromones and pheromone hound collars , in particular , had the highest level of calming effect on dogs and reduced concern and anxiety .

There are manycalming collarsthat you may apply as shock collar alternatives .

15. Physical Fencing

In some cases , frump shock collars are used to hold in a dog within specific boundary . These are often calledinvisible fence .

While this can be effective when used improperly , it can be harmful to domestic dog , and some pet proprietor see this as a cruel method acting .

It also does not stop other animals from get in into your dog ’s infinite and injure them , among many otherwireless fence cons .

Rather than using this type of negative reinforcing stimulus that does not keep your dog as safe as you might think , try installing a strong-arm fencing as one of the alternatives to daze collar for dogs .

If your region forbids fence , make use of goods and services of local dog parks , go for leashed walks , and make use of doggy daycare facilities .

16. A “Place”

Training your dog to realise one property as a topographic point to go to on command is beneficial for many reasons .

In this instance , if your heel is pain in the neck barking at the mailman , you may give your Fido the “ seat ” command , and they will discontinue barking and go to their destine place because he ’s conditioned to do so .

Many detent guardians apply a dog ’s crate or a dog ’s bed as a “ position ” that the pet will consider a secure position .

The “ place ” command must be repeatedly apply with positive kudos and threats and practise often .

It ’s best to utilise either clicker breeding or other reinforcement - based or obedience grooming methods for it .

17. Baby Gates and Barriers

While you are work with your pooch to get through job behaviour , as one of the alternatives to electrical shock collars for wiener , try using barriers orbaby gatesto moderate them .

For example , you could use a infant gate to keep your dog off from the window where they can see the mailman who make them to skin .

There are also specially design pet gates for dogs that can be either peregrine or stable barriers .

Thesepet gates , baby gates , and barrier are also helpful to have on hired hand for dogs that do n’t do well when crated .

They can be used to hold your dog-iron in a small space so that they are safe but still feel loose to move .

Finally , these types of gate and roadblock are also tinny than steady fencing or jounce collars for detent .

READ NEXT : How Dog Owners Justify Training Dogs with Shock Collars